nav toggle
x

Is It Better to Have an Above-Ground Pool or an In-Ground Pool?

Dive Into the Right Choice for Your Backyard

Dreaming of summer days spent poolside, but stuck on whether to go above ground or inground? You’re not alone. Many Utah, Idaho, and Wyoming homeowners face this very decision—each option has perks, tradeoffs, and potential surprises that could shape your entire outdoor lifestyle.

If you’re planning a pool that perfectly matches your space, budget, and long-term plans, this guide is here to help you confidently decide. We’ll break down what matters most—cost, customization, aesthetics, and maintenance—so you can choose the right fit for your home and lifestyle.

What We’ll Cover

  1. Above Ground vs Inground: The Big Picture
  2. Cost Comparison: Installation, Upkeep & Longevity
  3. Design & Customization Options
  4. Safety, Maintenance & Durability Factors
  5. What’s Best for Your Lifestyle?
  6. FAQs: Answering Common Pool Buyer Questions

Above Ground vs Inground: The Big Picture

At first glance, the main difference is obvious—one sits on the ground, the other is built into it. But the differences go far deeper:

Round above ground pool in a compact backyard setting

Above Ground Pools

  1. Typically faster and cheaper to install
  2. Available in pre-fab kits or customizable frames
  3. Best for temporary or seasonal use
  4. Easy to remove or relocate

Inground Pools

  1. Built for long-term use and property enhancement
  2. Allows for full custom shapes, sizes, and add-ons
  3. Adds more value to your home
  4. Greater aesthetic and functional flexibility

At Intermountain Aquatech, we’ve helped hundreds of families across Utah and surrounding states weigh these pros and cons based on their unique homes.

Cost Comparison: Installation, Upkeep & Longevity

Let’s talk dollars and sense.

Chart comparing costs of installing and maintaining above ground and inground pools

Initial Installation Costs:

  1. Above Ground: $1,500–$10,000 (including frame, liner, and setup)
  2. Inground: $35,000–$85,000+ (depending on materials, shape, features)

Maintenance Costs:

  1. Above Ground: Lower yearly cost; typically simpler equipment
  2. Inground: Higher cost, but more efficient systems and options for automation

Lifespan:

  1. Above Ground: 7–15 years on average
  2. Inground: 20–40+ years with proper care

Don’t forget to factor in long-term energy use, chemical needs, and replacement parts. Our team offers expert water care systems like Bioguard® and Caldera® Spas Water Care, which help keep maintenance manageable.

Design & Customization Options

If your vision includes waterfalls, tanning ledges, or a seamless spa integration, inground is the clear winner.

Luxury inground pool with built-in spa and custom features

Above-Ground Pool Design Limits:

  1. Generally round or oval
  2. Limited depth customization
  3. Basic decking can be added, but not integrated

In-Ground Pool Flexibility:

  1. Freeform, geometric, vanishing edge, and more
  2. Integrated spas, LED lighting, and custom materials
  3. Blends into a landscape with patios, fire pits, and outdoor kitchens

 

At Intermountain Aquatech, our in-home design consultations help you visualize the possibilities—and ensure your pool becomes a valid extension of your lifestyle.

Safety, Maintenance & Durability Factors

Pools should be fun and safe.

Covered inground pool showing child-safe features

Above Ground Safety Benefits:

  1. Elevated height makes accidental falls less likely for small children
  2. Simple fencing or ladder removal can add security

In-Ground Safety and Durability:

  1. Built to comply with stringent safety codes
  2. Can include automatic covers, fencing, and alarms
  3. Concrete or fiberglass options stand up to extreme weather better

With proper cleaning services and seasonal opening/closing support (yes, we do that!), maintenance becomes less of a chore and more of a routine.

What’s Best for Your Lifestyle?

Still unsure? Ask yourself:

  1. Do I want a luxury statement piece or something temporary?
  2. What’s my long-term plan for this home?
  3. Is budget more important now, or over the long run?
  4. Will I use the pool daily, seasonally, or occasionally?

Above Ground is ideal if:

  1. You’re budget-conscious or renting
  2. You want a quick installation for seasonal fun
  3. You prefer minimal maintenance

Inground is best if:

  1. You want to elevate your outdoor living space
  2. You’re seeking custom features
  3. You’re looking for lasting value and luxury

Design the Pool That Fits Your Life

Ready to design your dream pool? Whether above ground or inground, we’ll help you build an aquatic escape tailored to your home, lifestyle, and budget.

Explore Our Custom Pool Services

You can also get a free design consultation with one of our experts today.

Frequently Asked Questions

Not easily. Spas are much easier and more seamless to integrate with an inground system.

Rarely. Inground pools can enhance property value, especially when professionally designed and maintained.

Above-ground pools work well in tight spaces, but small custom inground pools or plunge pools are also great options.

Which Pool Is Right for You?

Choosing between an above-ground or inground pool isn’t just about cost—it’s about lifestyle, goals, and how you envision your summers for years to come.

Whether you’re looking to create a backyard oasis or just cool off after work, Intermountain Aquatech Pools & Spas is here to help you make the perfect choice.

Explore our full range of custom pool solutions or book your free design consultation today.

 

SeoPros
Follow Us
Latest posts by SeoPros (see all)